Q&A with Deputy Athletic Director Robert Ceplikas on the Northwestern Unionization Case and its Impact on Dartmouth

After football players at Northwestern University, with assistance from the National College Players Association advocacy group, moved in January to unionize, the university’s administration fought their efforts with legal action. I sat down last week with Dartmouth's Deputy Athletics Director Robert Ceplikas ’78 to discuss the Northwestern unionization case and its relation to Dartmouth athletics.

JS: How do you think the Northwestern Unionization case, which has received national attention, will impact Dartmouth?

RC: It won't have any direct impact because it only applies to athletic scholarships so the Ivies are immune from that since we don't offer athletic scholarships. Now this is my opinion, but I don't think it will hold up in the long run.

JS: There was an interview with the President Emeritus of Northwestern where he said the school could drop its sports programs. Do you think that would happen?

RC: I think that's a little extreme. I think it's a lot more likely Northwestern would maintain its programs and drop its scholarships.

JS: Could the right to unionize be extended to non-scholarship athletes?

RC: I have not seen any interpretation that would lead non-scholarship athletes to be affected by this anyway. The very basis of the ruling was that it's the scholarship that makes the student an employee.

JS: What if the case does make it's way to the Supreme Court and stands?

RC: Let's just say, hypothetically, that the ruling does get upheld all the way to the Supreme Court, then the main impact on the Ivies will be that the really selective, private institutions that are most affected, the Northwesterns, the Dukes, the Stanfords, they'll suddenly be looking for a very different type of athletic conference to compete in. They'll drop their athletic scholarships and they'll look for a conference like the Ivy League. It's not inconceivable, even though again I don't think this will actually happen to begin with, but if it did, it wouldn't be inconceivable that some of those schools would come knocking on the Ivy League's door and express some kind of interest, if not joining the Ivy League itself, in making some scheduling agreements because they'll be looking for competition from other non-scholarship schools that have similar academic philosophies. That could be a pretty major change if it ever came to that.